- Chilean Fire Barrel
- Chinese House Flowers prod. by John Darnielle
- Chinese Rifle Song prod. by John Darnielle
- Chino Love Song 1979 prod. by John Darnielle
- Choked Out prod. by Brandon Eggleston
- Cleaning Crew prod. by Trina Shoemaker
- Clean Slate prod. by Trina Shoemaker
- Clemency for the Wizard King prod. by Owen Pallett
- Cobra Tattoo prod. by Scott Solter
- Cobscook Bay
- Coco-Yam Song prod. by John Darnielle
- Cold Milk Bottle prod. by John Darnielle
- Collapsing Stars prod. by John Vanderslice
- Collapsing Stars (Demo) prod. by John Darnielle
- Color in Your Cheeks prod. by John Darnielle
- Commandante
- Corsican Mastiff Stride prod. by Matt Ross-Spang
- Corsican Mastiff Stride (The Jordan Lake Sessions Volume 4)
- Cotton prod. by John Vanderslice & Scott Solter
- Cotton (Jordan Lake Sessions Volume 2)